Autism therapy providers and advocates told reporters at a briefing on Tuesday, Nov. 17, that MassHealth's effort to take back 2024 payments from applied behavior analysis (ABA) providers is cutting into services for children with autism, CNHI statehouse reporter Christian M. Wade reported. The recoupment rests on a supervision ratio that the state Office of the Inspector General (OIG) measured in a March 1, 2024 report.

The ratio behind the clawback

MassHealth expects a Licensed Applied Behavior Analyst (LABA) to supervise behavior technicians for at least one hour for every 10 hours of direct ABA services. The OIG tested that ratio by comparing paid technician time (billing code 97153) with paid LABA supervision time (code 97155) in MassHealth managed care encounter data from Jan. 1, 2022 to Oct. 30, 2023. Its findings:

OIG findingAmount
Estimated overpayment for claims over the 10:1 ratio$16,761,445
Billing of more than 24 hours for one member on one day (627 claims)$439,632
Claims for services on holidays (561 claims, 311 members)$162,535

Together those total about $17.36 million, which is why news reports put the total at up to $17.3 million. On average, the OIG found one hour of supervision for every 7.78 hours of technician services, within the ratio. But 108 of the 562 providers it reviewed had claims for at least five members with ratios above 10:1. MassHealth spent almost $192 million on ABA for 9,328 members in fiscal 2023, according to the report. The OIG recommended that MassHealth review the data and decide whether to pursue recoveries.

How the recoupment has played out

Starting in February 2026, MassHealth directed its managed care plans to recoup 2024 ABA payments from providers that did not keep the 10-to-1 ratio, Behavioral Health Business reported in May. Letters from Tufts Health Plan and Carelon Behavioral Health described full or partial recoupment depending on how far a provider's overall supervision level fell below 10%. Provider groups, including Massachusetts Providers for ABA Access and Quality and the Massachusetts Association of Applied Behavior Analysis, called the ratio a clinical guideline rather than a condition of payment.

On Sept. 23, Autism Spectrum Therapies, a LEARN Behavioral company, sued in Suffolk Superior Court to void about $943,000 in demands for 2024 claims and recover about $117,000 it paid under protest. According to ABA Weekly's review of the complaint, the company argues that the ratio was never adopted as a regulation and that a state law, M.G.L. c. 118E, § 38A, bars most retroactive denials of behavioral health claims after 12 months. MassHealth has said it cannot comment on active litigation. As of early October, no hearing had been set.

The rules have since changed. A revised Massachusetts Behavioral Health Partnership/Carelon specification dated Feb. 15, 2026 requires LABA supervision of no less than 10% of direct service hours, and MassHealth's All Provider regulation amendments effective July 31, 2026 say managed care providers must follow performance specifications in their plan contracts, ABA Weekly reported.

What providers told reporters

Rebecca Thompson, chair of Massachusetts Providers for ABA Access and Quality, said many ABA operators are small businesses whose rates have not kept up with rising wages and costs. "They cannot continue to absorb escalating costs and unpredictable financial liabilities," she said. She warned of fewer appointments, longer waitlists and families losing ABA altogether. ABA clinician Sandy Beaton said shifting guidelines and treatment plans are confusing providers and families. A MassHealth spokesperson did not respond to CNHI before deadline.

What this means for providers and DSPs